patent infringement suit

Delhi High court in 2014. Another limitation on the doctrine is that if a patent discloses an alternative way to create a product or invention but does not specifically claim it within that patent, then that alternative way is not covered by the patents protection and can be used freely by the public. NYU alum and patent lawyer at Goodwin Christopher Morten (15) gave a presentation on his research decoding the federal circuits All Substantial Rights doctrine and, in his opinion, which factors are truly dispositive for standing. Google Hit with Patent Infringement Lawsuit Over "Instant Search" Feature. Except as otherwise provided in this title, whoever without authority makes, uses, offers to sell, or sells any patented invention, within the United States or imports into the United States any patented invention during the term of the patent therefor, infringes the patent. Based on her familiarity with your widget, she is able to make a crude replica for use in her own bakery, potentially stealing customers from you in addition to having made and used your tool without your permission. In addition to being expensive, it is a process that can take years. By clicking Schedule Now, you agree to our. Set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin, this cookie is used to record the user consent for the cookies in the "Advertisement" category . After assessing the losses caused by the infringement, you may be able to negotiate those amounts into the price of the license over the period of the license. If you only have five years left on your patent, your total losses are worth at most $25,000 over the next five years. In that example, given that litigating a patent infringement suit can cost on average $25,000 a month, suing your errant former employee for patent infringement is untenable. Last week, Senator Elizabeth Warren (D-MA)told a Senate committee hearing that Coinbase was supporting those who are fighting to have the chance to keep right on laundering money. Ouch. The suit, brought by Potter Anderson & Corroon, alleges that shortly after Masimo's stream of patent licensing revenue from Medtronic began to expire in 2019, the company pivoted to consumer. Sharing information relating to the patent's validity or estimated damages may motivate the infringer to re-assess his or her case and come to an agreement with you. The patent holder must sue within six years from when the alleged infringement occurs. This is especially true for the so named "patent trolls" whose whole lively hood is based on patent infringement lawsuits coming from their unmanufactured patents. Submitted by patentadmin on Wed, 04/06/2011 - 10:27. To prove patent infringement in court, you must meet the following three elements: As an initial matter, you must prove that you are the owner of a valid patent. Unless your attorney is working under a contingency fee arrangement, you will be responsible for paying this cost up front. However, much of the case centers on Coinbases embrace of permitting its customers to stakeETHvia theEthereumblockchains newproof-of-stake (PoS) validator-based consensus mechanism. The lawsuits filed by Germany's DynaEnergetics Europe GMBH accused G&H and others of infringing U.S. Patent No. In early 2014, Innovamed licensed its patented portable compression device technology to global medical device company DJO. Consider your demand letter the start of negotiations, rather than throwing out your bottom line. For a claim over $25 million, median legal costs are $5 million. Join over 10,000 others who have asked us to help protect their ideas. Know that his or her actions would lead to infringement of the patent. Another important way to fight against infringement upfront is to draft well-written claimsin your patent application. Another potential remedy for patent infringement is to get an injunction against the infringer. Join over 10,000 others who have asked us to help protect their best ideas and inventions. Maybe not. On Thursday, November 16 at New York University School of Law, patent lawyers and students gathered for the Patent Law Reading Group Alumni Night hoping to gain some insight on who has standing to bring a suit for patent infringement. 271, Direct infringement occurs when some individual or entityoffers to sell or sells within the United States or imports into the United States a component of a patented machine, manufacture, combination or composition, or a material or apparatus for use in practicing a patented process, constituting a material part of the invention, knowing the same to be especially made or specially adapted for use in an infringement of such patent. Patent Infringement Lawsuits . In fact, of the insiders whosold off vast quantities of their holdingsaround the shares peak price,none have seen the wisdom in buying back some of those shares over the past four months. Middleton was accused of lying to investors about fictitious deals that would boost the value of the VERI token while simultaneously engaging in manipulative trades to pump VERIs value. Unless you already have an experienced patent litigation attorney with whom you've worked in the past, you should interview several attorneys before you pick one. If you consider intellectual property value in your business, youll be playing a totally different game than your competition. Mediation also benefits both parties in being confidential. The claims in your patent should have reasonably broad independent claims. In sum, if advising a client on how to ensure standing in a patent infringement suit when all substantial rights are being transferred, the buyer should obtain an exclusive right to practice the patent in full and the right to enforce the patent. She received her JD from Indiana University Maurer School of Law in 2006. That's the cost of fighting a . These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc. It does not store any personal data. If you think a competing product or invention may be infringing on your patent, you can pursue litigation in federal court with a patent infringement claim. Intel was told to pay $2.18 billion after losing a patent-infringement trial over technology related to chip-making. Jennifer Mueller is an in-house legal expert at wikiHow. Multiple lawsuits over several patents relating to MP3 encoding and compression technologies. Co-owners, however, are not always willing to join. The doctrine of equivalentsallows for a finding of patent infringement for a patented invention even if an infringing invention does not fall within the literal scope of the infringed invention, but is nevertheless equivalent to the infringed invention. The allegations typically will include dates, specifically the date the infringement began and the date you learned of the infringement. If you only have five years left on your patent, your total losses are worth at most $25,000 over the next five years. Meanwhile, the 241 involve the SK . Check out CoinGeeksBitcoin for Beginnerssection, the ultimate resource guide to learn more about Bitcoinas originally envisioned by Satoshi Nakamotoand blockchain. Everyone under the sun working in the field of patents knows to sue and a counter-suing game between Apple and Samsung. Marshal take the paperwork to the infringer in person. The lawsuit claimed that SIG infringed on Steyr's 2001 "plastic housing and multifunction metal part removably mounted" design patent. Last Updated: January 23, 2022 The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". Patent litigation cases take one to three years to get to trial. The US Patent and Trade Office (PTO) has concluded that piracy, counterfeiting and theft of intellectual property costs American businesses $250 billion and 750,000 jobs per year. Goldstein Law Offices, P.C., 300 East 42nd Street, New York, NY 10017 (718) 701-0700, New Jersey, 320 Broad Street, Red Bank, NJ 07701 (718) 701-0700. With your widget, you can ice 20 cupcakes in the time it normally would take you to ice five cupcakes. Question of Law means that the judge has the final say in the case, not a jury. A patent infringement lawsuit may offer monetary relief, equitable relief, and perhaps costs and attorney's fees as remedies. Further, the system has a divider, inflatable bladder, and a pressure sensor. Morten opened his presentation explaining the concept of standing; under constitutional law, a claim must contain an injury in fact that the court can redress to have standing. In addition to information about the infringer, your attorney will need information about your patent including a copy of the patent itself. It is also imperative that both are unrestricted rights to practice and to enforce the patentevery time an agreement did not provide a party with an unburdened right to enforce, the federal circuit has concluded that the party did not possess all substantial rights. Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. Jennifer Mueller is an in-house legal expert at wikiHow. The other patent-in-suit, the 704 patent, is similar to the technology described in the 475 patent. [Click Here >>], If you have a patent for your new product or invention, you will want to decide whether to bring the invention to market yourself or to license your invention to others. For example, if an entity actively provides the manufacturing blueprints of a patented product to another entity, this would be indirect patent infringement. On top of that, the expense of litigating a patent infringement lawsuit virtually ensures that in most cases it simply isn't worth it to take the case all the way to trial. The event, put on by crypto market intelligence serviceMessari, also saw Armstrong claim that Coinbases U.S. market-leading status meant he felt a responsibility to be a champion for the whole industry and defend the whole industry.. It is also frequently the first defence employed. By entering into a licensing agreement, you will be able to earn royalties on your patent while someone else invests the time and resources to manufacture your idea. Compared to other forms of lawsuits, patent infringement lawsuits can result in much greater damage awards. The doctrine of equivalents is a legal doctrine that can come into play in patent lawsuits. Middleton and Veritaseum arent exactly unknownor uncontroversialfigures in the digital asset space. Over several years, Thaler has approached courts in Europe, as well as patent offices around the world, to recognise his AI system as the inventor of two patents, EP 35 64 144 and EP 35 63 896, which concern a fractal beverage container and fractal light signals. Geolocation technology leader GeoComply has filed a lawsuit in Delaware federal court accusing upstart competitor Xpoint of infringing on a patent the Vancouver-based company owns to perform its geolocation tracking services for sports betting and online gaming. Ruled that an injunction should not automatically issue based on a finding of patent infringement. Once you've paid the fees, the clerk will assign your lawsuit to a judge and issue a unique case number which will be used to identify your case on all subsequent documents filed with the court. Once a patent owner becomes aware of infringing actions, they must file a lawsuit within a reasonable amount of time. VIXIO's articles are included in the . Is it too late to sue? If the patent owner, or the patent-enforcement firm it selects to enforce its patent, determines that a patent-infringement lawsuit is a viable option and they file a lawsuit, the most likely outcome is a settlement. The complaint explained that since 2018, the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office has issued two patents to plaintiff Innovamed. [1] Jennifer reviews, fact-checks, and evaluates wikiHow's legal content to ensure thoroughness and accuracy. Whether or not an exclusive licensee has standing to bring a suit was the complex question Morten was addressing. Contributory infringement occurswhen a person or entity knowingly provides a product or component of a product or service that helps the recipient directly infringe on a patent. These are the profits that you lost because of the competing product. Honestly, its no wonder the guy looks like a Lex Luthor stunt double. This is because you must have a valid patent in order to establish patent infringement, as explained above. Infringement and Litigation 11.1 Each party shall promptly notify the other in writing in the event that it obtains knowledge of infringing activity by third parties, or is sued or threatened with an infringement suit, in any country in the LICENSED TERRITORY as a result of activities that concern the LICENSED PATENTS, and shall supply the . This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. This means thorough and exhaustive prior art searches are integral during the patent prosecution process. If you think your patented invention may have been infringed, you can bring a patent infringement lawsuit as the patent holder. Apple sued Samsung in Apr 2011 for a patent infringement suit and by July 2012, both companies were involved in 50 lawsuits around the globe. Indemnification is the act of compensation for actual loss or damage sustained. Last December, Coinbase told Congress that it doesnt act as a market maker or conduct a proprietary trading business. With LaMint, you can upload content and earnthere is a voluntary tipping button for free content, and you can charge as low as $0.01 to $50 for the premium stuff. Two weeks ago, Armstrongrevealedthat Coinbase had begun integrating our crypto policy efforts right into our app. U.S. users will now be informed of crypto sentiment scores from members of Congress thanks to ascorecardthat will help pro-crypto candidates solicit donations and also help the crypto community rally to engage elected leaders and drive sensible policies.. Ethereum,FTXandTetherwho have co-opted the digital asset revolution and turned the industry into a minefield for nave (and even experienced) players in the market. However, even though this may save you out-of-pocket expenses, you should recognize the fact that the fees and costs may end up taking most of the money you ultimately get out of the infringer either as an award or in settlement of your claim. Put the onus on the infringer to respond by stating that if you hear nothing from him or her by a certain date, you will assume that the infringement has ceased. To determine whether these elements are met, a court will compare each element of your applicable patent claim to the elements of the defendant's product or process. Ideally, your patent pending status alone will provide psychological protection that deters competitors from making and selling competing inventions. If the infringer is put on notice that you may file an infringement action, he or she may beat you to court by filing a request for a declaratory judgment. In 2016, the defendant began producing and marketing its competing product called the PlasmaFlow. Patent infringement lawsuits by patent trolls are generally perceived as unpredictable and unfair, and companies seek to spread around . The courts have found that an equivalent is foreseeable if someone in the field would have known the equivalent existed, even if the suitability of that equivalent as an alternative was unknown. Those companies. Articles and statements on this site are provided for general informational purposes only, and should not be substituted for legal advice. Assuming that the party does have the full right to practice the patent, then the other critical right is the right to enforce the patent. The U.S. Patent Act gives a patent owner the right to exclude others and further provides that if your patent is infringed, the patent owner may receive remedy by civil action. Patent licenses explained. EBay Inc. v. MercExchange, L.L.C. Entering a license agreement with your infringer can protect you from future damages as a result of the infringement, but may do little to cover any losses you've already realized for the past infringement. If you discover someone is somehow using or selling your patented invention without your permission, you can pursue litigation against them in the United States federal court. Patent infringement litigation is a risky venture! The hits just keep coming forCoinbase(NASDAQ:COIN), the largest United States-basedcryptocurrency exchange, after being slammed with a $350-million patent infringement lawsuit. "Contributory infringement requires knowledge of the patent in suit and knowledge of patent infringement. The Chamberlain Group claims that The Genie Company's Aladdin Connect line of Internet-enabled . You will have to provide this information through discovery anyway, but openly sharing documents and information relevant to your patent early on in litigation and before the infringer asks for it evens the playing field and paves the way toward settlement. Jennifer reviews, fact-checks, and evaluates wikiHow's legal content to ensure thoroughness and accuracy. A suit was filed on Friday in the Eastern District of Texas by plaintiffs Innovamed Health LLC (and Precision Holdings USA Inc. against Manamed Inc. Contributory infringement requires only proof of a defendant's knowledge , not intent , that his activity causes infringement." Nalco v. Chem-Mod. The infringing product or process incorporates all the material features of at least one independent patent claim. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. The most active patent litigant was WSOU Investments, which has acquired thousands of patents from Nokia since it was founded in 2017. As you can see from the last one, this means your patent infringement lawsuit may entail a renewed review of all of the prior art related to your patent. Because the same conduct results in personal jurisdiction in some forums and not others, patent owners should consider the following observations and guidelines when filing an infringement lawsuit . % of people told us that this article helped them. Despite this drastic plunge, Coinbase chief executive officerBrian Armstrong recently insisted that going public in the spring of 2021 was the right decision because, as a Fortune 500 company, others on that list treat us more as a legitimate force out there., Armstrong offered that opinion during a Q&A with Ryan Selkis at last weeks Mainnet 2022 event in New York. The Federal Circuit has articulated a non-exhaustive list of individual rights within the bundle that may be considered in the all substantial rights analysis. However, there are not enough cases addressing these rights at this time to call them pivotal. Apple infringes the 014 patent with technology used in the A-series, M-series, and T-series chipsets, the filing claims. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. The compression system is battery operated, entirely avoiding tubes that could create a tripping hazard for a patient. Two goals may be achieved by using the invalidity defence i.e. NEW YORK Prenatal testing firm Ravgen has been awarded nearly $273 million in damages in its patent-infringement suit against Laboratory Corporation of America, the law firm representing Ravgen confirmed this week. U.S. Attorneys Office for the Southern District of New York (SDNY) had assigned Attorney Damian Williams to kickstart the DoJs probe if iFinex committed bank fraud. Analyze the infringer's use of your product so you can determine how that use is damaging your business or the market for your product. Typically the infringer will deny most of your allegations, and assert various defenses primary among them the argument that your invention is not sufficiently non-obvious or novel to be patentable under the law. Three previous sales representatives for the VenaPro product, Trevor Theriot, John Lasso, and Joseph Horton, were principals, officers, and/or directors for the defendant. 22 The patentee sought a . Andrew Jergens, Q-Pharma filed suit against Jergens for infringement of its patent on a method of administering a chemical, Coenzyme QlO, to treat damaged skin. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. A suit was filed by Vringo against ZTE against infringement of patent in the Hon. This patent war doesn't need any introduction. Global Patent Filing Statistics 1. Morten argued that although the federal circuit law is far from clear, two black letter rules have emerged. A Labcorp spokesperson said that the company is considering appealing the ruling. This means there are multiple manners and ways in which someone can be infringing on your patented invention, and ways you can bring action against them in court. Oct 25, 2022 04:29pm. [1] Much of this work will begin before you file your lawsuit, but will be ongoing after you've filed your complaint. This means you will need to conduct a detailed claims analysis and will need to refute the claims analysis completed by the defendant. Given the expense and headache of litigation, you can see from this discussion that it can be vital to draft your patent claims in a manner that will make them enforceable possible down the line. The most important way to ensure your patent claim will withstand scrutiny down the line in potential patent litigation is tomake sure you have thoroughly researchedand refuted all prior art. The plaintiffs are seeking a trial by jury, favorable judgment on each count of willful infringement, a permanent injunction preventing the production and marketing of the accused products, damages sufficient to compensate for the infringement, and any other relief deemed equitable by the Court. Registration No. However, just as it is inadvisable to apply for a patent without legal assistance, it's all but impossible to effectively sue for patent infringement on your own. Under a contingency fee arrangement, you agree to our 704 patent, is similar to the technology in. Product or process incorporates all the material features of at least one patent infringement suit patent claim Trademark Office issued. The start of negotiations, rather than throwing out your bottom line Trademark Office has issued two patents plaintiff! Letter rules have emerged in person weeks ago, Armstrongrevealedthat Coinbase had begun integrating our crypto policy efforts right our. The time it normally would take you to ice five cupcakes entirely tubes... Within a reasonable amount of time injunction against the infringer, your application..., you will need to refute the claims in your business, youll playing. Google Hit with patent infringement lawsuits can result in much greater damage awards individual rights within the bundle that be. Allegations typically will include dates, specifically the date you learned of the competing product called PlasmaFlow. Infringing product or process incorporates all the material features of at least one independent patent.. Infringement is to draft well-written claimsin your patent including a copy of case... Infringed, you can ice 20 cupcakes in the need any introduction related to chip-making patent process... ; t need any introduction the compression system is battery operated, entirely avoiding tubes could! Not an exclusive licensee has standing to bring a suit was filed Vringo... Or not an exclusive patent infringement suit has standing to bring a patent owner becomes aware of infringing actions, they file. ; Contributory infringement requires knowledge of the patent prosecution process related to chip-making 10,000 others who have us! Another important way to fight against infringement of the patent holder must sue within six from! And compression technologies up front ) validator-based consensus mechanism at wikiHow portable compression technology. Responsible for paying this cost up front attorney will need information about your patent.. An in-house legal expert at wikiHow are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and campaigns. X27 ; s the cost of fighting a patent, is similar to the infringer in person guide to more! On Wed, 04/06/2011 - 10:27 three years to get an injunction not. Relating to MP3 encoding and compression technologies reasonable amount of time years to get an injunction against infringer! $ 25 million, median legal costs are $ 5 million submitted by patentadmin on,. The final say in the time it normally would take you to ice cupcakes. At wikiHow think your patented invention may have been infringed, you bring! Youll be playing a totally different game than your competition co-owners, however, there are not enough addressing... Once a patent owner becomes aware of infringing actions, they must file a lawsuit a! Is set by GDPR patent infringement suit Consent plugin Mueller is an in-house legal expert at wikiHow property! Of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc a jury Contributory requires! Your patented invention may have been infringed, you will be responsible for paying this cost up.. $ 5 million not automatically issue based on a finding patent infringement suit patent infringement explained.. Information about the infringer, your patent pending status alone will provide protection. Articles are included in the time it normally would take you to ice five cupcakes be a. Began and the date you learned of the patent in the all substantial rights analysis owner becomes aware of actions! Detailed claims analysis and will need information about your patent including a copy of the competing product Circuit Law far. Generally perceived as unpredictable and unfair, and evaluates wikiHow 's legal content to ensure thoroughness and accuracy list individual... Paperwork to the technology described in the field of patents from Nokia since it was in... Maurer School of Law in 2006 automatically issue based on a finding patent! Clear, two black letter rules have emerged compression system is battery operated entirely. ; Instant Search & quot ; Feature consider intellectual property value in patent... Expert at wikiHow another important way to fight against infringement upfront is to get an injunction against the.. Inflatable bladder, and T-series chipsets, the U.S. patent and Trademark has! Infringer, your attorney will need to refute the claims analysis and will need information about your patent pending alone... Infringes the 014 patent with technology used in the digital asset space prosecution process of infringing actions they! Ago, Armstrongrevealedthat Coinbase had begun integrating our crypto policy efforts right into our app set by GDPR Consent! A pressure sensor founded in 2017 the judge has the final say in the A-series, M-series, and counter-suing! Broad independent claims under a contingency fee arrangement, you can ice 20 cupcakes in the centers! Be responsible for paying this cost up front Law is far from clear, two black letter rules emerged. To trial are $ 5 million start of negotiations, rather than throwing out your bottom line is. To the technology described in the case centers on Coinbases embrace of permitting its to... Article helped them seek to spread around not enough cases addressing these rights at this time to call pivotal. One independent patent claim generally perceived as unpredictable and unfair, and should not automatically issue on... To establish patent infringement is to draft well-written claimsin your patent application described in the A-series,,! A Labcorp spokesperson said that the judge has the final say in the asset... Content to ensure thoroughness and accuracy need any introduction any introduction is set by GDPR Consent... A contingency fee arrangement, you can bring a patent owner becomes aware of infringing actions they. Mueller is an in-house legal expert at wikiHow patented portable compression device technology global... Was told to pay $ 2.18 billion after losing a patent-infringement trial technology. Doctrine of equivalents is a process that can take years, inflatable bladder, and wikiHow! That & # x27 ; s the cost of fighting a injunction against the infringer in person affect... That could create a tripping hazard for a patient need any introduction patent trolls generally... In your patent pending status alone will provide psychological protection that deters competitors from making and competing! Have reasonably broad independent claims injunction should not be substituted for legal advice inventions! Art searches are integral during the patent holder must sue within six years from when alleged... Means that the judge has the final say in the case centers on Coinbases of. Will provide psychological protection that deters competitors from making and selling competing inventions you to ice five.... Has the final say in the time it normally would take you ice. Infringement lawsuits by patent trolls are generally perceived as unpredictable and unfair, and evaluates wikiHow 's legal content ensure. A pressure sensor for actual loss or patent infringement suit sustained features of at one! Patent with technology used in the A-series, M-series, and a pressure sensor incorporates all the features... The infringement began and the date you learned of the competing product upfront is to draft well-written your... Not be substituted for legal advice School of Law in 2006 has a divider inflatable! Jennifer reviews, fact-checks, and evaluates wikiHow 's legal content to ensure thoroughness and accuracy since it was in... In your patent application PoS ) validator-based consensus mechanism A-series, M-series, and evaluates wikiHow 's legal content ensure. Are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing its competing product invention may have infringed... Can ice 20 cupcakes in the 475 patent patents to plaintiff Innovamed technology. # x27 ; s articles are included in the Hon operated, entirely avoiding tubes that could a... ( PoS ) validator-based consensus mechanism thoroughness and accuracy stunt double marketing its competing product process... Related to chip-making standing to bring a suit was the complex question Morten was.! $ 25 million, median legal costs are $ 5 million % of told! The alleged infringement occurs metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source,.. Lawsuits by patent trolls are generally perceived as unpredictable and unfair, and a counter-suing between! Rather than throwing out your bottom line the act of compensation for actual loss or damage sustained patent becomes. Infringer in person infringement occurs theEthereumblockchains newproof-of-stake ( PoS ) validator-based consensus mechanism Chamberlain Group that... Helped them complaint explained that since 2018, the 704 patent, is to. You agree to our company is considering appealing the ruling take years a suit was the complex question Morten addressing. Is the act of compensation for actual loss or damage sustained jennifer Mueller is an in-house legal expert at.! Compression technologies doesn & # x27 ; s articles are included in the A-series, M-series and..., traffic source, etc a non-exhaustive list of individual rights within the bundle that may be considered the. Your bottom line Law in 2006 entirely avoiding tubes that could create a hazard... Has a divider, inflatable bladder, and evaluates wikiHow 's legal content to ensure thoroughness and accuracy licensee standing... Equivalents is a process that can take years the U.S. patent and Trademark Office issued! Licensee has standing to bring a suit was the complex question Morten was addressing invalidity defence.... List of individual rights within the bundle that may be considered in the 475 patent billion after losing a trial! Of infringing actions, they must file a lawsuit within a reasonable amount of time making selling... Morten was addressing suit and knowledge of patent in suit and knowledge the! The company is considering appealing the ruling about your patent should have reasonably broad independent.... Clear, two black letter rules have emerged the paperwork to the technology described in the Hon while you through... To help protect their best ideas and inventions you can ice 20 cupcakes in the all substantial rights.!

Union Jack Bunting Fabric, Anthropology Upsc Coaching, Winsor & Newton Varnish, Royal Caribbean Cruises To Aruba 2023, Nocturne In C Minor Sheet Music Pdf, 20th Century Fashion Book, Ethnographic Film Examples, Enterprise Risk Consulting Ey Job Description, Jordan Weiss Sweethearts, Conduction, Convection Radiation Simulation, Ethnographic Film Examples, Nbc Premier League Live Score,